Ian,
I agree with you in all aspects of what you are trying to achieve with this post, being the information distribution of incidents and technical defects of aircraft components, be they limited to a particular type or generically applicable to all.
Yes, I believe there should be a place where all defects should be listed without regard to whose aircraft it is and I would think that your forum here would be an ideal place to list people's experiences and problems with mechanical issues.
From an administrators point of view, yes, theoretically, all defects should be reported to the office. Defects that are reported, get published in the magazine under pilot and technical notes. Unfortunately, many defects that are reported never have the resultant root causes reported, so we have a copy of the problem, but do not know what the cause of the problem was.
Another reason why it would be good to have a database of issue on this forum is for those times when hearsay becomes fact, like the mass balance falling off the Texan. Caz has made it clear in no uncertain terms that this claim is not correct.
With regard to maintenance, lets face it, some people are simply pilots and have no interest in maintenance. Others wouldn't know where to start looking when conducting maintenance.
That is the attraction and the downfall of our org, people can do what they like (most of the time), yet they also don't tend to talk to anyone when things go wrong (or let the office know).
It is not any easy topic to 'cure', though will slowly come around through education (which I am working on trying to deliver) and peer pressure (relying on everyone else out there to do the right thing and confront others when they are doing the wrong thing). Especially with maintenance.
If you have a place on the forum for defect reports, perhaps I can find some time to put a few entries in.
Regards
Chris