My feeling is that; as with so much else aviation related, the answer isn't either or but both, - as you become more experienced and familiar with a given aircraft, you feed in whatever controls are necessary to achieve your aims, anticipating the secondary effects you will either use or have to overcome. The answer is closer to one extreme or other depending on the aircraft too, I recall that Tiger Moths are described as requiring the rudder to lead the way into a turn and the Drifter is a bit that way too.