No...It's a completely different set of circumstances.
I have no problem with paying landing fees, but I do have a problem with RAAus's inability to safely handle my personal details.
Letting anyone have access to my data just because they are an instructor is a different kettle of fish.....what could go wrong you ask?
Just because you are nice , well balanced character doesn't mean that all instructors are I have met more than one with a serious god complex and at least one that was the holy trinity. He not only had the god complex , but also the saviour complex and thought he was everywhere at once.
These people shouldn't have access to much at all, they take it upon themselves to rewrite histories and make themselves the hero.
To add to that, most students have no idea of what's going on with that instructor type until they go to a different one and even then may not realise what was going on until much later in their flying life.
Do your BFR, charge what you like, assess them as necessary, advise them as necessary, fill out the logbook, send them on their way and let them manage their details, they aren't children.